The Keeper of Lost Things by Ruth Hogan - listened on Libby for almost ten hours

This audiobook started out delightfully and I appreciated the wonderful descriptive similes for the first several hours. The characters were interesting and the setting of the beautiful home and gardens was comforting. The story had several interweaving episodes that made following a little difficult at first, but I was able to keep them straight eventually.

I was quite captivated at first...but it soon became evident that these characters were one-dimensional and flat. I persevered to the end, though, because some of the magic or ghosts were slightly intriguing and I wondered how the author would pull them all together. They all came together, all neatly tied up.

I enjoyed the British accent, the very clever turns of phrases...but overall, too fluffy. And the occasional F-bombs were so needless. Too bad. 

I guess fluff just doesn't get it for me anymore! In between listens, I was studying Doctrine & Covenants 124 for teaching Gospel Doctrine, and listening to meaty podcasts about that. The contrast between fluff and meat became startling!

The Kiss of a Stranger by Sarah M. Eden 8.5 hours on Libby

 Well, I always wondered about Covenant Communications and their "proper romances," and now I know! Thanks to our Ridgeview Ward book club, and Karen Lossee, we are reading this one and another one for our group. And since I enjoy these women so much, I'm carrying on. And I especially enjoy Karen and her thoughts and comments on what we've read. So, I was kind of surprised at the inanity of this book! She warned us it was a lightweight, and she was correct. I do have to say, though, that I enjoyed it sometimes. Lightweight can be fun, but this was too much, too silly, and too long. The plot was absolutely absurd and the premise was nuts, and yet, I could have lived with that except the prolonged misunderstanding between the two potential lovers went on and on and on. I thought at one point, this would be a good novella. Or even a short story. But over 8 hours of this absurdity? But that's on me... When I went to the library to look for the second one she recommended, I saw a whole shelf full by this author! Not the Persphone one that we will be reading, however. It's okay, I don't think I need to waste any more time on this genre. 

The handsome Lord Cavratt kisses the beautiful Catherine in a garden to blunt the advances of another suitor. Catherine's uncle insists he marry her, and so he does, and the rest of the story is absurd legal machinations that would never happen in a million years. But still... The absolute reliance on the opinion of others and the polite society was reminiscent of Jane Austen's work, I wonder if that's what the author was going for? What society thinks and the gossips, etc., got very tiresome to hear about. Okay, enough ranting. I will try to be kind when we meet to discuss this book. The good news is, it kept me amused sometimes on long hot summer walks!

The Jane Austen Project bu Kathleen A. Flynn - on Libby audio - 11 hours

 This author, Kathleen A. Flynn, was chosen by Natalie Jenner, the author of The Jane Austen Society, to interview Natalie for an endpiece to her audio book. Jenner mentions in the interview that she chose Flynn because she so admired what she had accomplished in this book on Austen. That intrigued me, because I really enjoyed Jenner's book, and value her opinion. I'm not fond of fantasy or sci fi, so this was a stretch, but because it came so highly-recommended, I went for it.

It was a fascinating listen on many levels! The story begins in the future when two people are chosen and trained to travel back to Jane Austen's time. The few aspects of the future that are revealed are interesting and believable. The tension that's created with wondering if they'll be able to return to their own time after their research keeps the story lively. And the philosophical and ethical dilemmas abound! Like, how much are they interfering in the "probability field" that will change the outcome of history? Is it too much to help a poor chimney sweep's boy? Or to give medical care to Jane to prolong her life and thus enable her to write more?

In addition to these dilemmas, of course there is sexual tension between the two researchers, a man and a woman from the future, trying to fit in to Jane Austen's world and win her confidence. Those struggles are fascinating too. It's just fascinating in every regard, though it also felt a bit dark at times. I liked how Jane Austen and her brothers were portrayed, and it was fun to hear the researchers and Jane discuss some of her characters. There' is an abundance of information and dates about what was going on in Jane's life when, much more than I was aware of. It made me want to go walk the countryside around Chawton and see the places that feel almost familiar to me now. 

There are some rather graphic sex scenes, but not too much...And Flynn did an excellent job in capturing the tone of conversations from that time period. It was an expecially fun listen for 11 hours! It helped me prolong my walks around our new Monterey Drive neighborhood!

Black Beauty by Anna Sewell

I found this delightful book in my shelf of classics as we prepare to downsize from out townhome to (possibly?) an apartment to accept a calling in Bismarck. I am trying to decide what is worthy of keeping in hard copy vs. what is ripe to give away. And is it worth saving for the grandchildren?

I'm not sure about this one. I enjoyed the sweet little stories that make up each chapter, but they were not exciting. I mean, I enjoyed them, but not sure a younger reader (like John or Henry) would. I loved learning about the life lessons each of Black Beauty's owners taught, and what stood out most was the love and care for and value of family. It also contains a lot of vignettes that reveal how the poor in England, and in London in particular, survived during this transition between the horse era and the "modern" era of trains, etc. I've always been intrigued by this time period and the tragic way life was lived in order to survive, particularly the children.

I am a horse-lover, so I enjoyed hearing things from his (Black Beauty's)point of view. I'm not sure I treated our horses (while I was growing up) with the care I should have--this book definitely advocates for kindness in training!

This particular copy is old, and probably why it's still around is that it has a Paso Robles address hand-written in it. I'm wondering how it came to us. Perhaps from Grandma Louise Austin? Still, I think it's a give-away. It was enjoyable and light reading, good lessons, but not probably one I will pick up again.

The Tontine by Thomas B. Costain

When we were home in Napa at Christmas, I asked my 91-year old father for a recommendation for a new book for me. I was there longer than anticipated, and had finished everything I had brought along with me. My dad and I happen to love some of the same books (Story Like the Wind; A Far-Off Place, for example), so I was hoping he would have a good suggestion for me. He did! And not only did he recommend it, my sister Ann chimed in and said she had enjoyed it too. And, best of all, he had a copy of it I could keep awhile.

From the first page, I was taken in! Costain weaves a delightful history of life in England around the time of Napoleon's defeat. It's an ambitious undertaking as he follows the lives of several families and generations as England becomes industrialized. The main family, the Carboy's, are importers and factory owners. There's love, there's intrigue, there's peerage, and there's all manner of human frailties. Costain's tone is quite witty; he has a sometimes acid eye as he describes the foibles and interactions of the characters. Sometimes I would laugh out loud at his observations.

The story spans three or more generations and is divided into two volumes. I found the first volume much funnier than the first, but the story carried me right along in the second. It took me awhile to track down and order the second volume, so I had a few weeks in between. By the end of the story in the second volume, I couldn't remember some of the people that the story had circled back around to. So I started back at the beginning of the story in Volume 1, and realize that from the very beginning there is LOTS of subtle foreshadowing of things to come. It's very enjoyable to notice these on the second time through.

Costain's characters are fascinating and memorable. They also tend to be pretty much altruistic (Helen Groody) or stubbornly greedy (Sam Carboy). Although the good ones have their weak moments, the greedy ones seldom have any redeeming qualities; at least any that we can see. What they profess early in their lives (Isabelle Carboy, for example, wanting to marry a duke) stays consistent over the course of their lives. The English passion for their knighted and decorated heroes is fun to read about.

One thing I enjoyed was the comforting world that the author creates around the good characters. It feels reassuring to see good being rewarded with peace! Their lives are not always easy and they suffer serious setbacks, but their peace remains. That's a good thing.

The books I read were published in 1955 and the several pen and ink illustrations by Herbert Ryman in each volume are spare and charming. All in all, worthy of keeping and visiting again in a future lazy day!

July 2016
So...just coming out of a very difficult period...this pair of books (Volume 1 and 2) were a delightful retreat from reality as my brain adjusted to a new phase of life. We moved into a townhome and moved Irene in with us; she's 92 and this has dramatically changed our lives. When things were tough, I would gratefully retreat down to our cool walk-out basement and lose myself again in this wonderful story. I was so exhausted every day, that this was book was also a great reward at night before crashing. It took me over a month to read both this time around, and it was well worth it!

April 2022
I just finished it again! What a delightful story with great characters! We are now living in St. George, and it was a nice spring read when I needed something to help me sleep. I love this story and these characters. I might have to branch out and try a few more of this author's. It's amazing the detail he goes into as he describes the events of the three generations this epic novel spans. We see child labor exploited, we see heroes helping to get child-protection laws passed, we see Napoleon's family trying to gain the throne again, and we see the massive wealth built in England by Sam Carboy utterly lost in a depression.  So enjoyable! It's a keeper, for sure. And kind of bittersweet, now that Daddy is gone, that I can't revisit the story with him.