Although not listed in this blog, I believe I read another of this author's books, probably The Christmas Box. I have a vague memory of wondering why people thought it was good. I would love to find a good Christmas story, but that wasn't it. I have seen this author's books featured at Deseret Book often, and sail right past them because of that one experience. But I often wondered, maybe he's improved over time?
So, when our Stonebridge Ward book club had this one on the list, and it looked like a Christmas story too, I was game to give him another try. Well, by the first chapter, I knew it was just more pulpy, predictable fluff. It's too bad because the packaging is attractive, and so is the idea. Another disappointment is that it's not even a Christmas story! It's a "love" story. Huh. NOT. So superficial, so predictable, it became annoying. And there is a lot of dialogue that is supposed to be clever that is just plain pedantic and annoying.
One problem may be that I was also reading The Q by Beth Brower, who is a master of clever dialogue and rich characters. The contrast was startling. I would not have even finished Christmas in Bethel if it weren't for the book club discussion ahead.
This abused girl, Leigh Beth, who goes by Beth, has a hard life, is very damaged and insecure, but somehow attracts the attention of an author whom she says saved her life. She meets him ahead of a book signing, at a coffee shop, which again, is so predictable. We know right away that this is the author. As the unbelievable story unfolds, we are treated to more banal dialogue, a falling in love story surrounded with all the trappings of a rich and famous life...and of course a couple of misunderstandings and falling outs. Turns out this famous author is a fake; it's his brother who is the true author, but that's forgivable because he's mentally unstable. All of it is just plain annoying.
The one redeeming aspect of this book is the quotes from Beth Stilton's diary at the beginning of each chapter. Some of them are clever. Here are some examples:
"Please don't judge me too harshly. The jury in my own head is merciless enough and rarely adjourns."
"Alice was our book club's moderator tonight. I'm proud of her, fighting her fear of being herself and owning her voice. Maxine was her usual self. Too much self , too much voice."
And here's one that reflects the "wisdom" of this author: "I learned more about love in one moonlight walk than a thousand romance novels. It is a true irony, that the victory of love is found in surrendering to it."
Sheesh. Spare me.