Saturday, November 14, 2026

The Christmas Bookshop by Jenny Colgan

 This is our December book for our Monterey book club. It had some good points, but it's very much a Hallmark movie kind of book. No depth. The saving aspect, that kept me reading, though, was the fascinating description of Edinburgh. I had no idea it had so many unique aspect. It sounds like it was built on hills and the houses and businesses are built higgelty pigglety all over... It made me want to visit, despite it also being icy cold!

Carmen is an immature, bitter, younger sister of Sofia, a successful mother and lawyer. You kind of want to wring her neck when she constantly takes umbrage at everything her sister says to her... It's a frustrating read at times. And the book seller, Mr. McCredie, is an unlikely and unrealistic person, as are Carmen's romantic interests: Oke and Blair. 

Carmen's sarcasm and wit and ineptitude win over her nieces and nephew and draw the animosity of Sofia's nanny, Skylar. There's a lot of junior high bantering over the romantic interests in the story and it's a little frustrating to read... All in all, meh. Although it was fun to watch Carmen turn into the aunt that the children learned to appreciate. This author has a long list of other books, with similar names to this one... I won't be reading them...

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Christmas by the Book by Anne Marie Ryan - 10 hours on Libby

 This one was suggested by Janet in one of our book clubs as a possible Christmas read; it looked intriguing, and so I downloaded it and listened to it while I sewed and did the grandkids' photo books. 

It's fluffy, and frustratingly detailed, but the details are designed to create the cozy, warm, loving atmosphere that is like a Hallmark movie. It's sweet, and the characters are mildly challenged, and of course the rise to the challenge, they do not develop, they are unrealistic, yet lovable, etc., etc., down to their cute little white terrier. Still, the story was interesting enough to keep me connected as the various characters came together in interesting ways.

Despite the fluff, there is a good message here. As the little village bookshop struggles to stay alive, the owners ask people to nominate someone in the community who could use a Christmas surprise or uplift. Six people are chosen, Nora and Simon choose six books, and deliver them. These books turn out to completely change the people they are given to...They help with grief, depression, an out of work actor, etc., etc., What I like about the message is that you never know where your generous deeds might lead. These people turned a big corner, inspired by a great book. Each one was very different, and that was clever. It shows the profound effect a good deed and a good book can make. Unrealistic in the telling? Yes, but I do believe in miracles, and it was a nod to this abiding belief of mine. Would I recommend it? Probably not, although I do want to read "The Greatest Gift," since that is the book that inspired the movie, "It's a Wonderful Life." Lots of books were recommended in this one, but most I've already heard of...

Sunday, November 8, 2026

Whistler by Ann Patchett

 My neighbor Sandy Petersen mentioned at book club that she had read this, and I expressed an interest in it. The next thing I knew, she brought it over. It's a signed copy by Ann Patchett herself, which Sandy got on her recent trip to Nashville. So of course I've had to be very careful with it!

I didn't intend to read it right away, but after perusing the first few sentences, I was hooked. I really like Patchett's gentle style, and very engaging milieu. It definitely called to me and I was so curious about how the story would unfold.

Daphne Fuller unexpectedly meets her former stepfather on a museum trip with her husband. Eddie Triplett left her life when she was nine years old, but their bond was strong. She feels such love and admiration from him, that she wants to reconnect and they forge another strong bond. The story is full of reminiscing, and unfinished stories. I wanted to know how they would all unfold. The dialogue is witty and smile-inducing as well as poignant. Eddie is a delightful person who seems to light up the lives of everyone around him. Daphne is still his favorite person, and his love for her gives her new energy and purpose. 

Daphne's relationship with her sister is one that I also enjoyed, as they shared such intimacy and comfortable closeness. As they navigate their relationship with their mother, it's an interesting story too. There is pain, and disappointment, but there is also beautiful forgiveness and acceptance. I just enjoyed and savored the entire story. 

It was also revealing that when secrets are kept, fractured families result... Failure to accept reality and to live less than honestly has definite tradeoffs. These were interesting to think about...

Sunday, November 1, 2026

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever by Barbara Robinson; narrated on Libby by C.J. Critt

 The Stonebridge group, Marcia's group, settled on this book after I maligned the Christmas in Bethel book that was on our schedule. Everyone jumped on this one because it's short and fairly well-known as a good choice.

Frankly, I was disappointed. I thought it would be better. I think I read it when Sierra was reading it, back in the day, and we agreed it was cute and funny. But now it feels kind of trite and predictable... Yes, it has a good message about the "true" meaning of Christmas, and how the mean church people mistreat the naughty Herdman children...but it was kind of annoying to listen to. It was interesting too, to note that as late as the seventies, when this was written, that Dad expected Mom to have dinner on the table, etc. It proves to be an interesting little time capsule about how times and roles have changed!

This only took an hour and a half to listen to on Libby, and it held my interest. But it was borderline annoying...so, no more! I have to find a worthy Christmas read and suggest it to the group!

Stitched by Eli McCann

 I get occasional reels from Eli McCann and enjoy his humor and am always curious about his lifestyle as a former Mormon, gay married father, with an extended family who loves him and accepts him. He's been posting about this book and how proud he is of it, and I was curious about it. I knew it was about Utah women quilters, and loosely based on his mother's quilting group. But I was reluctant to purchase it. Low and behold, it showed up at the gym in the giveaway box! I snatched it up!

And...it is very disappointing. The dialogue is meh, the characters are meh, the plot unbelievable, just all around MEH. I kept reading thinking, hoping it would get better it did not. This is not Eli's genre! Back to the gym it goes...

I will now, again, give myself permission to stop reading when a book is BAD. Yet, I seem to keep doing it! Ah, well...NO MORE!!!

Friday, October 23, 2026

Lady Tremaine by Rachel Hochhauser - Listened to on Libby - 13 hours - read by Bessie Carter

 This title kept being mentioned by some of the book recommenders I follow on Instagram, so I got in line on Libby and finally got to listen to it. It was an enjoyable romp, the perfect motivation to get out and walk while Len and I were staying at the Springhill Suites in Cedar Park, visiting Sierra and her family. We had a beautiful pool area and lake and walking path, where I could walk and watch sunsets and listen to this story. Very enjoyable, although it took awhile for me to get into it.

The Cinderella story told from the stepmother's viewpoint was clever with some believable/contextual aspects. Like a traveling minstrel/junk dealer named Mouser who transforms his carriage to take Ellen to the ball. The prince is no prize, and as his story unfolds, we see the fallacies of pursuing an aristocratic life, or a life built on appearances. It's a long listen, with interesting forays into the world of falconry, making way as a woman in a time of great suppression, and an evil queen. It gets a little graphic, but not too gross. Ethel, the main character, ruminates often about her role as a mother and what it means to launch your daughters into society; and do you give up all of your own desires for them? Some of her thinking was interesting...her devotion was admirable, given her dire circumstances. Making her way, and eventually deciding to save her stepdaughter, were interesting to watch as they unfolded. It wasn't realistic, though, or maybe it was? that she kept her counselor on as a friend and protector, but wasn't willing to marry him. Interesting dilemma...

I wouldn't say it was worth recommending to anyone, but it was good to get me out and walking. 

Christmas in Bethel by Richard Paul Evans

 Although not listed in this blog, I believe I read another of this author's books, probably The Christmas Box. I have a vague memory of wondering why people thought it was good. I would love to find a good Christmas story, but that wasn't it. I have seen this author's books featured at Deseret Book often, and sail right past them because of that one experience. But I often wondered, maybe he's improved over time?

So, when our Stonebridge Ward book club had this one on the list, and it looked like a Christmas story too, I was game to give him another try. Well, by the first chapter, I knew it was just more pulpy, predictable fluff. It's too bad because the packaging is attractive, and so is the idea. Another disappointment is that it's not even a Christmas story! It's a "love" story. Huh. NOT. So superficial, so predictable, it became annoying. And there is a lot of dialogue that is supposed to be clever that is just plain pedantic and annoying.

One problem may be that I was also reading The Q by Beth Brower, who is a master of clever dialogue and rich characters. The contrast was startling. I would not have even finished Christmas in Bethel if it weren't for the book club discussion ahead.

This abused girl, Leigh Beth, who goes by Beth, has a hard life, is very damaged and insecure, but somehow attracts the attention of an author whom she says saved her life. She meets him ahead of a book signing, at a coffee shop, which again, is so predictable. We know right away that this is the author. As the unbelievable story unfolds, we are treated to more banal dialogue, a falling in love story surrounded with all the trappings of a rich and famous life...and of course a couple of misunderstandings and falling outs. Turns out this famous author is a fake; it's his brother who is the true author, but that's forgivable because he's mentally unstable. All of it is just plain annoying. 

The one redeeming aspect of this book is the quotes from Beth Stilton's diary at the beginning of each chapter. Some of them are clever. Here are some examples:

"Please don't judge me too harshly. The jury in my own head is merciless enough and rarely adjourns."

"Alice was our book club's moderator tonight. I'm proud of her, fighting her fear of being herself and owning her voice. Maxine was her usual self. Too much self , too much voice."

And here's one that reflects the "wisdom" of this author: "I learned more about love in one moonlight walk than a thousand romance novels. It is a true irony, that the victory of love is found in surrendering to it."

Sheesh. Spare me.