The Frozen River by Ariel Lawhon

I don't think I would have read this book, from its description, if I hadn't wanted to be able to discuss it in our Monterey book club. I'm so glad I did! It's one of the best books I've read in a long time. Such good characters, such ethical and strong characters were what propelled this forward for me. Plus, the time period showing what every day life was like in the late 1700's was fascinating.

Martha Ballard is a real historical person, and so are most of the characters in this book. But the story is fictional, which the author clearly explains in the Author's note at the end. It also showed me a lot about the early judicial system of the Maine territory, the culture of that area, and the early upper crust of Boston and Harvard. 

The Ballard family was a happy one to learn about, despite the early deaths of three of their daughters. The rape of women and the powerlessness of women in general was treated with clarity and reality. Yet Martha Ballard was an extraordinary outlier who made a difference in her sphere. I loved being privy to her thinking. I enjoyed the clues that dropped like breadcrumbs along the way as to the murder of one of the two villains in the story. It also felt to me like divine justice was done when the "civilized" justice system failed. I had the sense all along that things would work out...

The difficult birth scenes and violence were not gratuitous and not hard for me as they propelled the story along. I liked the setting of the river and how it impacted life.  I enjoyed the humor as Martha fought her cantankerous horse....for a heavy topic, this story also felt light. I will definitely explore more from this author. 

Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus

 I finally figured out the free Libby library app, and was able to listen to the amazing novel about an uncompromising woman Chemist from the sixties whose sensibilities were wayyyyy ahead of her time, and probably could have only be written in retrospect. 

I enjoyed the characters, the dog, and the way the story told the backstories of the characters. Although they were all somewhat extreme and cartoonish, they had real things to say and brought the theme to life. The way the different threads came together at the end was marvelous to behold.

HOWEVER! The notion that scientists have to be dishonest or deny evidence to believe in God is utter trash and completely untrue! I understand the frustration with religion and the hate it can spawn when misguided, but still, I don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. And I don't even believe women were so "religious" in the sixties, the way they were portrayed. To posit atheism as the main character's philosophy, based on "science" and as a natural conclusion, was disingenuous at best. All science and all evidence-based vs. religion is a false dichotomy and I didn't like the way it was woven and portrayed.

And yet...there is truth in the notion that many traditions will keep people oppressed and women especially. 

The plot moved beautifully forward and I envied Elizabeth Zott's commitment to do what she felt was right, no matter the consequences. 

I also enjoyed the notion that chemistry and cooking are about life and are important. Well done. Mostly okay language, too, with a few exceptions. Rather graphic rape scene, but it served a purpose.

Listening to this story was delightful and made my walks and housecleaning very enjoyable!